How to Avoid Common Mistakes to Optimize Your Drug Testing Policy

Press Releases
17 May 2023
4 min read

Overall drug use and alcohol use in the United States is on the rise. According to the National Center for Drug Abuse Statistics (NCDAS), almost 32 million people (11.7% of the population) were actively using drugs as of 2021, with marijuana, prescription stimulants, and methamphetamines as the most popular drugs of choice.

Is your company prepared to support the issues that accompany a rise in workplace drug use? Drug testing can help keep everyone in your company safe and prevent employee performance issues and keep workplace safety in check.  

Common Mistakes When Updating a Drug Testing Policy

These factors can lead to common mistakes when developing or revamping your drug testing policy and ideas to help avoid them.

Failure to Create a Drug Testing Policy at Your Organization

A policy keeps everything in order and outlines the company goals and objects of the testing program. By implementing rules and requirements in a policy, companies can ensure the appropriate guidance is provided to help maintain consistency and ensure safety. A successful program starts with a written policy.

When a policy is absent it inevitably creates inconsistencies, uncertainties, and overall confusion. 

At a minimum, a good written drug testing policy should contain at a minimum the following important elements.  

  1. The program objectives
  2. The applicable laws
  3. Who is covered under the program
  4. The substances that will be tested for
  5. Specimens for testing
  6. Program prohibitions
  7. Drug and alcohol testing procedures

A written policy is the first line of defense for employers, and it establishes the program expectations for the employees. The policy sets forth the company’s rules and procedures and can be utilized to justify disciplinary decisions. When these decisions are challenged, the policy will be front and center. 

Not Having a Clearly Defined Policy

Having a written policy is the starting point and the first step towards creating an effective drug-free workplace. But it is equally important to establish clear-cut policies to articulate the requirements for management of the program and for employees to know where they stand and what is expected from them. 

The policy content should be straightforward and precise. It should be specific, and it should not contain language or words that can lead to misinterpretation. Nothing is more frustrating than have written processes so complex you need to rely on step-by-step instructions or processes so vague that you have no idea what is really required/expected. 

For example, many employers have a policy that requires testing in post-accident situations. Simply outlining that testing will occur in post-accident situations will undoubtably lead to confusion. It isn’t necessary to have a play-by-play instruction guide, but it is important to clearly outline:

  • the criteria that will trigger a post-accident test
  • who will be subject to testing
  • when testing will occur
  • any violations for failing to report an incident

Applying a Blanket Approach

When it comes to constructing a testing program, there are a series of questions that should be evaluated to determine the best approach for your company. Not every company is the same and there is no policy that fits all programs. There are many questions to consider when developing a program and the answers vary depending on state laws, company culture, and program goals and objectives.  

Building a cookie cutter policy into your company testing program involves designing guidelines that will most likely not benefit your company’s testing program and has proven to involve drawbacks including liability concerns.

Not Tailoring your Policies to Fit Your Company Needs

As mentioned above, the first step is to review the company’s drug testing objectives. In other words, what does the company hope to achieve by revising the existing drug testing policy or creating a new policy? Have the company objectives changed from the initial roll out of the policy? Has your company expanded to different states or added employees regulated under the Department of Transportation? Perhaps you are now interested in developing a policy that allows an employer to receive a discount on workers’ compensation premiums or to deny unemployment or workers’ compensation claims?  

Identify the testing objectives. This will set the conditions for how the policy will be written.  

Failing to Amend the Policy 

it can be difficult to keep up with the changes in the drug testing trends, industry standards, and federal or state drug testing laws and a company policy can quickly become obsolete. At the same time, it may be the opportune time to evaluate your testing program to ensure it is still working for you. Do you need to add or increase/decrease random testing? Is there a better alternative to your current testing methodology to enhance your testing program? 

Perhaps the company’s goals, objectives, and operational needs have shifted which may necessitate a policy change to align with the company’s mission.

Just like with any process you implement to enhance efficiency or reduce compliance risk, it is important to revisit it periodically to determine if it remains as effective as when first applied. Evaluating your current process and understanding drug testing best practices can reduce the risk of adding a drug abusing employee to your team.    

Make it routine practice for regular reviews of the policy and the company’s testing program objectives. Policy maintenance should be assigned to an individual or department. Identifying an owner for this project will make your investment in the drug testing program a more rewarding effort

If company polices have not been reviewed in a few years, most often companies will elect to start fresh with the policy. However, reviewing an existing policy and incorporating any omissions or updates is certainly a viable option.


Don’t make these drug testing policy mishaps. Establishing a clear, compliant, and custom policy early on and sticking to it can help avoid these common drug testing mistakes moving forward. 

This article was written by Sharon Bottcherour and our friends at The Current Consulting Group, LLC. It was originally published on CCG’s site. This information is provided for educational purposes only. Reader retains full responsibility for the use of the information contained herein.

Why Orange Tree?

Orange Tree Employment Screening helps companies win their race to fill open positions by providing fast and easy background check and drug testing services. We are committed to helping companies create safer workplaces, mitigate financial risk, and avoid legal exposure. We forge long-term partnerships with our clients by offering a full range of technology-led screening solutions predicated on best practice and legally defensible screening programs.